Skip to content

Buy 4 single sheets of Gift Wrap (mix & match), get the 5th sheet FREE -or- get 20% off 5 of the same Sheets! Discount automatically applied at checkout.

  • Shop
    • All Products
      • NEW! Just Added
      • Halloween & Thanksgiving
      • FINAL SALE!
      • Milkfarm Merch
    • Greeting Cards
      • ALL
      • Anniversary, Engagement & Wedding
      • Baby
      • Birthday / Belated
      • Congratulations, Encouragement & Retirement
      • Get Well & Sympathy
      • Everyday
      • Love
      • Mom & Dad
      • Teacher Appreciation & Graduation
      • Thank You
      • Boxed Sets & Packs
    • Stationery & Paper
      • ALL
      • Books & Bookmarks
      • Gift Wrapping Supplies
      • Notepads & Notebooks
      • Office Supplies
      • Stickers & Washi Tape
    • Clothing & Accessories
      • ALL
      • Baby & Kids
      • Bags & Pouches
      • Bandanas, Beanies & Hats
      • Clothing & Footware
      • Jewelry, Hair Clips & More
      • Lapel Pins & Patches
    • Homegoods, Kitchen & Bar
      • ALL
      • Aprons & Kitchen Towels
      • Bar
      • Blankets, Pillows & Rugs
      • Candles
      • Kitchen
      • Prints
    • Sundries & Fun Things!
      • ALL
      • Magnets
      • Keychains & Keyrings
      • Stress Balls
      • Puzzles & Games
      • Foodie Pet Toys
  • Gift Cards
  • Contact Us
Log in
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Parchment Paper logo with phrase "culinary gifts and stationery" underneath.
  • Shop
    • All Products
      • NEW! Just Added
      • Halloween & Thanksgiving
      • FINAL SALE!
      • Milkfarm Merch
    • Greeting Cards
      • ALL
      • Anniversary, Engagement & Wedding
      • Baby
      • Birthday / Belated
      • Congratulations, Encouragement & Retirement
      • Get Well & Sympathy
      • Everyday
      • Love
      • Mom & Dad
      • Teacher Appreciation & Graduation
      • Thank You
      • Boxed Sets & Packs
    • Stationery & Paper
      • ALL
      • Books & Bookmarks
      • Gift Wrapping Supplies
      • Notepads & Notebooks
      • Office Supplies
      • Stickers & Washi Tape
    • Clothing & Accessories
      • ALL
      • Baby & Kids
      • Bags & Pouches
      • Bandanas, Beanies & Hats
      • Clothing & Footware
      • Jewelry, Hair Clips & More
      • Lapel Pins & Patches
    • Homegoods, Kitchen & Bar
      • ALL
      • Aprons & Kitchen Towels
      • Bar
      • Blankets, Pillows & Rugs
      • Candles
      • Kitchen
      • Prints
    • Sundries & Fun Things!
      • ALL
      • Magnets
      • Keychains & Keyrings
      • Stress Balls
      • Puzzles & Games
      • Foodie Pet Toys
  • Gift Cards
  • Contact Us
Log in Cart

Item added to your cart
Remove all

1249 products

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

1249 products

Remove all
Remove all

1249 products

  • A yellow faux-leather keychain wallet shaped like a butter carton and a matching hexagonal tag, both attached to gold-tone hardware and a white key ring, on a white background. A yellow faux-leather keychain wallet shaped like a butter carton and a matching hexagonal tag, both attached to gold-tone hardware and a white key ring, on a white background.

    Butter Bag Charm

    Butter Bag Charm

    Regular price $12.00
    Regular price Sale price $12.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Butter Barb Sticker Butter Barb Sticker

    Butter Barb Sticker

    Butter Barb Sticker

    Regular price $4.00
    Regular price Sale price $4.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Ivory knit beanie with "BUTTER" in blue embroidery. "Butter" beanie shown next to "chicken nuggets" beanie and "dill pickles" beanie.

    Butter Beanie

    Butter Beanie

    Regular price $34.00
    Regular price Sale price $34.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Greeting card that is half speckled light blue on top and white/black checkerboard on the bottom. Top of the card reads "Butter days ahead!" Below it are three sticks of salted butter

    Butter Days Greeting Card

    Butter Days Greeting Card

    Regular price $5.50
    Regular price Sale price $5.50
    Unit price /  per 
  • Yellow gift bag with 'butter' text on a white background

    Butter Gift Bag

    Butter Gift Bag

    Regular price $8.00
    Regular price Sale price $8.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Greeting card with butter on it with text that reads "Butter late than never. Happy birthday!"

    Butter Late Than Never Birthday Card

    Butter Late Than Never Birthday Card

    Regular price $5.50
    Regular price Sale price $5.50
    Unit price /  per 
  • White towel with 'BUTTER' text on a white background White towel with 'BUTTER' text on a white background

    Butter Me Up Tea Towel

    Butter Me Up Tea Towel

    Regular price $27.00
    Regular price Sale price $27.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Butter keychain on a Rifle Paper Co. branded card

    Butter Not Lose 'Em Enamel Keychain

    Butter Not Lose 'Em Enamel Keychain

    Regular price $24.00
    Regular price Sale price $24.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Large list style notepad designed to look like outer wrap on stick of butter Large list style notepad designed to look like outer wrap on stick of butter

    Butter Risograph Notepad

    Butter Risograph Notepad

    Regular price $20.00
    Regular price Sale price $20.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Tufted rug made to look like a stick of salted butter Dog sitting on 5 stacked butter rugs.

    Butter Rug

    Butter Rug

    Regular price $38.00
    Regular price Sale price $38.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Kitchen towel with a vibrant blue background and 5 yellow butter sticks design Breakfast-themed kitchen cloth set with a toaster on a beige surface

    Butter Sticks Dishtowel

    Butter Sticks Dishtowel

    Regular price $16.00
    Regular price Sale price $16.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Butter Stress Ball Butter Stress Ball

    Butter Stress Ball

    Butter Stress Ball

    Regular price $12.00
    Regular price Sale price $12.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Butter than Ever Birthday

    Butter than Ever Birthday

    Butter than Ever Birthday

    Regular price $5.50
    Regular price Sale price $5.50
    Unit price /  per 
  • Butter Together Love Card

    Butter Together Love Card

    Butter Together Love Card

    Regular price $5.50
    Regular price Sale price $5.50
    Unit price /  per 
  • Greeting card with a butter illustration and text "all things are butter with you" on a pink background Greeting card with a butter illustration and text on a pink background

    Butter With You Food Love Card

    Butter With You Food Love Card

    Regular price $6.50
    Regular price Sale price $6.50
    Unit price /  per 
  • Heart-shaped yellow sticker with 'BUTTERED NOODLES' text on a white background Heart-shaped sticker with 'Buttered Noodles' text held in a hand outdoors

    Buttered Noodles Candy Heart Sticker

    Buttered Noodles Candy Heart Sticker

    Regular price $4.00
    Regular price Sale price $4.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • 2 sheets of buttered popcorn scratch & sniff sticker sheets

    Buttered Popcorn Scratch & Sniff Sticker Sheets

    Buttered Popcorn Scratch & Sniff Sticker Sheets

    Regular price $8.00
    Regular price Sale price $8.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Birthday card with a cake slice and ice cream scoop illustration on a blue background

    Cake and Ice Cream Happy Birthday Friends Card

    Cake and Ice Cream Happy Birthday Friends Card

    Regular price $6.00
    Regular price Sale price $6.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Pink box of cake napkins with illustrations on a white background Napkin cake slices and coffee cups on a white background

    Cake Cocktail Napkins - Set Of 4

    Cake Cocktail Napkins - Set Of 4

    Regular price $44.00
    Regular price Sale price $44.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Patterned paper with cartoon characters on a pink background Patterned gift wrap sheet with cartoon cats and desserts on a pink and orange background

    Cake Time Gift Wrap Sheet

    Cake Time Gift Wrap Sheet

    Regular price $5.50
    Regular price Sale price $5.50
    Unit price /  per 
  • Cakes & Bows Gift Bag Cakes & Bows Gift Bag

    Cakes & Bows Gift Bag

    Cakes & Bows Gift Bag

    Regular price $8.00
    Regular price Sale price $8.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • A novelty sushi roll candle shaped like a maki roll, with white rice, green avocado, and crab filling details, topped with sesame seeds and a small flame burning from the top. It sits on a round wooden slice coaster on a wooden table with cucumber slices blurred in the background. Three sushi roll candles with avocado and crab on a wooden board.

    California Roll Sushi Candle

    California Roll Sushi Candle

    Regular price $24.00
    Regular price Sale price $24.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Package of Cameron's Corner pepperoni slice natural rubber baby teether on a white background Child holding a toy pizza slice outdoors

    Cameron’s Corner Pepperoni Slice Teether

    Cameron’s Corner Pepperoni Slice Teether

    Regular price $22.00
    Regular price Sale price $22.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • Illustration of a vintage-style sardine can label on a colorful geometric background Risograph print with Ortiz Sardinas branding on a sardine can illustration on a colorful background

    Can of Sardinas Risograph Print

    Can of Sardinas Risograph Print

    Regular price $13.00
    Regular price Sale price $13.00
    Unit price /  per 
  • 1
  • …
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • …
  • 53

The Meat & Potatoes

  • Shipping FAQ
  • Refund Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Information

The Icing on the Cake

Parchment Paper is brought to you by your friends at Milkfarm Artisan Cheese Shop. We are a specialty gift shop that is dedicated to Food-Lovers and all things FOOD! The store carries a well-curated selection of food-centric stationery/paper goods, gifts, specialty kitchenwares, and other sundries. We strive to support small independent artisans and their craft, while stocking the store with fun and unique finds.

Oh, and we have awesome, full-service gift wrapping with FOOD-centric paper, of course!!!

Subscribe to our emails: The Tasty Times

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Payment methods
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
© 2026, Parchment Paper Powered by Shopify
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.